Recently I was asked to be a judge for the Manchester regional Flash Fiction Slam held by the New Hampshire Writers' Project. More important than scoring was giving useful critique to the writers as a tool to improve their stories.
At the heart of providing useful critique is your intention: are you sure you want to help make what you're reviewing better. If so, even if you're not completely in love with all the details, you'll be sensitive to the creator(s) and also ask tough questions.
Even with the best intentions, framing the critique can be tough. Here are some tips to help you stay on track.
Be specific
Whether it's something you like or dislike, be specific. Saying I don't like this "story/idea/concept/etc" does not help anyone. Saying I really like your use of the word "x" or what your did with the design of "y" will help to identify the parts that may need adjustment
Start on a positive note
Asking for critique can make creator(s) feel vulnerable. Try starting on a positive note with something you like first to help ease the conversation.
Don't assume you're right
Before pointing out areas you think could be improved, don't automatically assume you know its true purpose. Ask the creator(s) questions to find out more information. An example: I'm not sure why you placed this here, are you trying to accomplish "x"? Your questions can also help the creator(s) think about the project in ways they hadn't before.
Curious about the Flash Fiction Slam? Listen to NHPR's Audio Postcard and join them for the finals in Manchester on March 6.
No comments:
Post a Comment